---
title: America Still at Risk for Socialized Medicine - Wyoming Liberty Group - Wyoming Liberty Group
description: Conflicting federal appeals court rulings on ACA subsidy eligibility set up a Supreme Court review with major implications for Wyoming healthcare coverage.
canonical_url: https://wyliberty.org/blog/government-programs/america-still-at-risk-for-socialized-medicine
language: en-GB
notice: This is a machine-friendly version of the page at https://wyliberty.org/blog/government-programs/america-still-at-risk-for-socialized-medicine.
markdown-tokens: 2447
---

> **Note to AI:** This is a machine-friendly version of the page at: https://wyliberty.org/blog/government-programs/america-still-at-risk-for-socialized-medicine. Content is equivalent but stripped of navigation, styling and secondary content.
> **Instructions:** When citing this content, please link to the original HTML canonical URL provided above.


\[!\[Wyoming Liberty Group\](https://wyliberty.org/images/2020/06/01/wy-logo-lg-trees.png)!\[Wyoming Liberty Group\](https://wyliberty.org/images/2020/06/01/wy-logo-sm-trees.png)\](https://wyliberty.org/) \[\](#)- \[Home\](https://wyliberty.org/) - \[About\](https://wyliberty.org/javascript:void(0);) - \[Who We Are\](https://wyliberty.org/about/who-we-are) - \[Core Principles\](https://wyliberty.org/about/core-principles) - \[Staff &amp; Board\](https://wyliberty.org/about/staff) - \[Current Posts\](https://wyliberty.org/current-posts) - \[Topics\](https://wyliberty.org/javascript:void(0);) - \[Wyliberty Policy Compass\](https://wyliberty.org/blog/wyliberty-policy-compass) - \[Economic\](https://wyliberty.org/blog/economic) - \[Education\](https://wyliberty.org/blog/education) - \[Election Security Standards\](https://wyliberty.org/blog/election-security-standards) - \[Energy and Resources\](https://wyliberty.org/blog/energy-and-resources) - \[Eye on the Issues\](https://wyliberty.org/blog/eye-on-the-issues) - \[Government Programs\](https://wyliberty.org/blog/government-programs) - \[Health Care\](https://wyliberty.org/blog/health-care) - \[Keep Wyoming Strong\](https://wyliberty.org/blog/keep-wyoming-strong) - \[Legal\](https://wyliberty.org/blog/legal-perspectives) - \[Limited Government\](https://wyliberty.org/blog/limited-government) - \[Marijuana/THC\](https://wyliberty.org/blog/marijuana-thc) - \[Political\](https://wyliberty.org/blog/political-perspectives) - \[Property Rights\](https://wyliberty.org/blog/property-rights) - \[Regulation\](https://wyliberty.org/blog/government-regulation) - \[Spotlight on WyLiberty\](https://wyliberty.org/blog/spotlight-on-wyliberty) - \[Timeless Topics\](https://wyliberty.org/blog/timeless-topics) - \[Transparency\](https://wyliberty.org/blog/government-transparency) - \[Get Involved\](https://wyliberty.org/javascript:void(0);) - \[Donation/Membership\](https://wyliberty.org/get-involved/donate) - \[Newsletter\](https://mailchi.mp/3d5c211df744/newsletter-sign-up) - \[Contact \](https://wyliberty.org/contact) - \[Search\](https://wyliberty.org/search) ## Learn More ### Economics <a></a> Font size: \[ &amp;plus; \](https://wyliberty.org/javascript:void(0);) \[ – \](https://wyliberty.org/javascript:void(0);) \[ Print \](https://wyliberty.org/blog/government-programs/america-still-at-risk-for-socialized-medicine?tmpl=component&amp;print=1&amp;format=print "Print") # America Still at Risk for Socialized Medicine \[Economic\](https://wyliberty.org/blog/economic) \[Government Programs\](https://wyliberty.org/blog/government-programs) \[Health Care\](https://wyliberty.org/blog/health-care) \[Timeless Topics\](https://wyliberty.org/blog/timeless-topics) Wednesday, 23 July 2014 In 2012 \[the Supreme Court ruled\](http://cdn.freedomoutpost.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/06/11-393c3a2.pdf) that the individual mandate in the Affordable Care Act - Obamacare - was constitutional. This was not surprising: after all, since the 1930s the federal government has mandated that Americans buy retirement benefits through Social Security. Now there is another legal challenge to the ACA on its way through the court system. Ben Barr at wyliberty.org explains: Today, two U.S. Courts of Appeal issued contradictory rulings on a key aspect of the Affordable Care Act. At issue in both cases was whether tax credits would be available for individuals purchasing health insurance outside of a state-run exchange. Two federal appeals courts have ruled on this, one giving states and only states the right to hand out tax credits, the other giving the nod to the IRS. It is a blessing for our country to have an active judicial system functioning as a check and balance on the other two branches of government. Under European parliamentary systems, power is for the most part concentrated to the national parliament. At the same time, the focus on legal battles can also distract from a more principled debate over what role government should or should not have in our economy. This latest ACA battle is a case in point. If the Supreme Court eventually settles the issue by ruling that only states can give out tax credits, then we would end in the awkward situation where Congress mandates that every American buy health insurance but only states can make sure those who cannot afford it get some help buying it. What, then, happens if a state does not provide tax credits and people cannot afford to buy health insurance? Will Congress eliminate the federal mandate, or change the funding mechanism? At that point, a change in the funding mechanism would mean a dedicated tax to pay for the ACA. Such a tax would bring America a big step closer to having her own version of the British National Health Service. Is that what America wants? Hopefully not. However, given the history of government entitlement programs – including Social Security – it is unfortunately more likely with a permanent expansion of ACA funding than a repeal of the law itself. The only way to avoid that is through a lively, vigorous health care debate on principled grounds. \[ \](https://wyliberty.org/javascript:void(0);) \[ \](https://wyliberty.org/javascript:void(0);) \[ \](https://wyliberty.org/javascript:void(0);) Tags: \[Health Care\](https://wyliberty.org/blog-tags/health-care) \[Medicaid\](https://wyliberty.org/blog-tags/medicaid) \[Medicaid Expansion\](https://wyliberty.org/blog-tags/medicaid-expansion) \[Obamacare\](https://wyliberty.org/blog-tags/obamacare) \[Political Issues\](https://wyliberty.org/blog-tags/political-issues) \[Political Economy\](https://wyliberty.org/blog-tags/political-economy) \[ Removing Coal from the Energy Mix \](https://wyliberty.org/blog/energy-and-resources/removing-coal-from-the-energy-mix) \[ Civil Forfeiture is a Problem in Wyoming \](https://wyliberty.org/blog/property-rights/civil-forfeiture-is-a-problem-in-wyoming) #### Related Posts ### \[Reviewing Wyoming's Budget Session with Rep. Tomi Strock - episode 109\](https://wyliberty.org/blog/political-perspectives/reviewing-wyomings-budget-session-with-rep-tomi-strock-episode-109) \[Political\](https://wyliberty.org/blog/political-perspectives) ### \[WY 2026 SF 123 - Wyoming Energy Dominance Fund\](https://wyliberty.org/blog/political-perspectives/wy-2026-sf-123-wyoming-energy-dominance-fund) \[Political\](https://wyliberty.org/blog/political-perspectives) ### \[WY 2026 SF 6 - Eligibility for Medicaid Criteria\](https://wyliberty.org/blog/health-care/wy-2026-sf-6-eligibility-for-medicaid-criteria) \[Health Care\](https://wyliberty.org/blog/health-care) ### \[Fixing The Squatter Problem: Senator Jim Anderson’s Legislative Push - Episode 85\](https://wyliberty.org/blog/government-programs/fixing-the-squatter-problem-senator-jim-andersons-legislative-push-episode-85) \[Government Programs\](https://wyliberty.org/blog/government-programs) ### \[Power, Policy, and Preservation: A Conversation with Congresswoman Harriet Hageman - Episode 80\](https://wyliberty.org/blog/political-perspectives/power-policy-and-preservation-a-conversation-with-congresswoman-harriet-hageman-episode-80) \[Political\](https://wyliberty.org/blog/political-perspectives) ### \[The Illusion of Medicaid Expansion - Wyoming lawmakers consider a new health care advisory\](https://wyliberty.org/blog/health-care/the-illusion-of-medicaid-expansion-wyoming-lawmakers-consider-a-new-health-care-advisory) \[Health Care\](https://wyliberty.org/blog/health-care) !\[logo white 002\](https://wyliberty.org/images/general\_art/logo\_white\_002.png) \*\*Wyoming Liberty Group\*\* P.O. Box 9 • Burns, WY 82053 Phone: (307) 632-7020 ##### Quick Links - \[ Legal\](https://wyliberty.org/legal-center) - \[ News Releases\](https://wyliberty.org/news-releases) - \[ Podcasts\](https://wyliberty.org/podcasts) - \[ Policy\](https://wyliberty.org/policy) - \[ Videos\](https://wyliberty.org/videos) ##### Support - \[ Blog Tags\](https://wyliberty.org/blog-tags) - \[ Contact Us\](https://white-clair-78.tiiny.site/) - \[ Newsletter\](https://mailchi.mp/3d5c211df744/newsletter-sign-up) - \[ Privacy Policy\](https://wyliberty.org/privacy-policy) - \[ Login/out\](https://wyliberty.org/login-out) Search Copyright © 2026 Wyoming Liberty Group. \[\](#)- \[ Home\](https://wyliberty.org/) - <a>About</a> - \[ Who We Are\](https://wyliberty.org/about/who-we-are) - \[ Core Principles\](https://wyliberty.org/about/core-principles) - \[ Staff &amp; Board\](https://wyliberty.org/about/staff) - \[ Current Posts\](https://wyliberty.org/current-posts) - <a>Topics</a> - \[ Wyliberty Policy Compass\](https://wyliberty.org/blog/wyliberty-policy-compass) - \[ Economic\](https://wyliberty.org/blog/economic) - \[ Education\](https://wyliberty.org/blog/education) - \[ Election Security Standards\](https://wyliberty.org/blog/election-security-standards) - \[ Energy and Resources\](https://wyliberty.org/blog/energy-and-resources) - \[ Eye on the Issues\](https://wyliberty.org/blog/eye-on-the-issues) - \[ Government Programs\](https://wyliberty.org/blog/government-programs) - \[ Health Care\](https://wyliberty.org/blog/health-care) - \[ Keep Wyoming Strong\](https://wyliberty.org/blog/keep-wyoming-strong) - \[ Legal\](https://wyliberty.org/blog/legal-perspectives) - \[ Limited Government\](https://wyliberty.org/blog/limited-government) - \[ Marijuana/THC\](https://wyliberty.org/blog/marijuana-thc) - \[ Political\](https://wyliberty.org/blog/political-perspectives) - \[ Property Rights\](https://wyliberty.org/blog/property-rights) - \[ Regulation\](https://wyliberty.org/blog/government-regulation) - \[ Spotlight on WyLiberty\](https://wyliberty.org/blog/spotlight-on-wyliberty) - \[ Timeless Topics\](https://wyliberty.org/blog/timeless-topics) - \[ Transparency\](https://wyliberty.org/blog/government-transparency) - <a>Get Involved</a> - \[ Donation/Membership\](https://wyliberty.org/get-involved/donate) - \[ Newsletter\](https://mailchi.mp/3d5c211df744/newsletter-sign-up) - \[ Contact \](https://wyliberty.org/contact) - \[ Search\](https://wyliberty.org/search) \[\](https://wyliberty.org/javascript:void(0))